Nairobi skyline for business-focused legal counsel in Kenya
Thought Leadership

Business-focused legal counsel.

Business-focused counsel for companies, institutions, investors and private clients.

For businesses seeking investment, the question is usually framed in terms of what makes the company attractive to capital: growth, profitability, market opportunity, management capability and financial performance. Increasingly, another question may be equally consequential, whether the business falls within the investor’s mandate at all.

ESG exclusionary investing introduces a different dimension to investment decision-making. Rather than assessing only whether a prospective investment presents an attractive risk-return proposition, an investor may determine that certain businesses, activities or exposures are outside the parameters of the capital it manages.

The practice is not new. Investors have long applied exclusionary screens to sectors or activities considered inconsistent with their investment mandates or institutional policies. These may include controversial weapons, tobacco, certain fossil-fuel activities, severe environmental harm or serious human-rights and governance concerns. What has changed is the increasing sophistication of the criteria applied and the potential consequences for businesses seeking institutional and international capital.

Exclusionary investing is sometimes treated as an ESG preference sitting alongside the investment decision. In practice, it can form part of the investment decision itself. An investor may be subject to a mandate that prohibits investment in specified sectors or activities, or imposes thresholds beyond which an investment cannot proceed. The relevant criteria may arise from the investor’s own policies, the requirements of its underlying investors, regulatory obligations, financing arrangements or broader institutional commitments.

The legal and commercial significance of an exclusion policy lies partly in the precision of its definitions. A broad statement that an investor will not invest in companies associated with a particular activity may provide useful policy direction, but it does not necessarily answer the questions that arise during due diligence. For example, a company may not itself conduct an excluded activity but may have exposure through a subsidiary, joint venture, contractor, supplier, financing arrangement or particular revenue stream.

An investor assessing a Kenyan business may therefore examine more than the company’s principal business activity. It may consider its group structure, material subsidiaries, joint ventures, contractual relationships, sources of revenue and financing arrangements to determine whether an exclusion is engaged.

For businesses, this means that ESG investability may depend not only on what the company does, but also on how its business is structured and where its economic relationships sit. This is where exclusionary investing moves decisively from the sustainability function into the transaction itself.

If an investor’s mandate prohibits investment in a particular activity, the issue may affect whether the investor can participate in the transaction at all. Where participation is possible, the relevant ESG considerations may influence valuation, transaction structure and the allocation of risk between the parties. These considerations may also find their way into the legal documentation through representations and warranties, disclosure obligations, conditions precedent, use-of-proceeds restrictions, information and reporting requirements as well as ongoing monitoring obligations.

An ESG issue that began as an investment-screening criterion can therefore become a contractual matter. This is particularly important for businesses preparing for institutional investment. The objective should not simply be to establish that the company is legally compliant. Management should understand the investment criteria likely to be applied by prospective investors and identify, in advance, any areas that may require explanation, mitigation or restructuring.

It is also important to distinguish between screening an investment before capital is committed and divesting an existing investment. A prospective investment may be excluded because it falls outside an investor’s mandate. An existing investment, however, may become subject to an exclusion following a change in the company’s activities, ownership, revenue profile or applicable investment criteria. The consequences can be materially different.

A screening decision may determine whether a transaction proceeds. A divestment decision may raise questions concerning exit timing, liquidity, contractual restrictions, portfolio-management obligations and the treatment of an investment that subsequently becomes inconsistent with an applicable mandate.

For companies, understanding these distinctions is critical when negotiating investment documentation and considering the longer-term implications of bringing particular categories of institutional capital onto the shareholder register.

For Kenyan businesses seeking institutional, international or development-oriented capital, the implications are increasingly relevant. A company may be commercially viable, financially attractive and fully compliant with applicable Kenyan law, yet still fall outside the investment mandate of a particular fund. That is not necessarily a finding of wrongdoing or non-compliance. It may simply reflect the investment parameters governing that particular pool of capital.

As Kenyan businesses seek to attract international investors, development finance, private equity and other institutional capital, understanding the ESG parameters of prospective investors can therefore become part of investment readiness. Companies may need to understand not only their own ESG profile, but also the extent to which their group structures, revenue streams, suppliers, contractors, investments and financing arrangements could trigger an investor’s exclusion criteria.

For investors, exclusionary screening can provide a mechanism for aligning capital allocation with defined environmental, social and governance parameters. For businesses, it introduces another dimension of capital-market risk. The question is no longer simply whether a business can demonstrate strong financial performance or compliance with applicable law. It may also be whether the business is compatible with the investment mandate of the capital it seeks to attract.

That makes ESG exclusionary investing relevant not only to sustainability teams, but to boards, founders, management teams, investment committees, transaction advisers and legal counsel.

As ESG considerations become increasingly embedded in investment mandates and transaction documentation, exclusion criteria are likely to have consequences well beyond an investor’s screening process. They can influence due diligence, valuation, transaction structure, contractual risk allocation and, ultimately, a company’s access to particular pools of capital.

At Manoah & Company Advocates, we advise businesses, investors and institutions on ESG risk, investment transactions, corporate structuring, regulatory compliance and commercial contracting. We help clients understand how ESG considerations can translate into practical implications for transactions, governance, risk allocation and access to capital.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *