Nairobi skyline for business-focused legal counsel in Kenya
Thought Leadership

Business-focused legal counsel.

Business-focused counsel for companies, institutions, investors and private clients.

Sustainability has moved from the margins of corporate communications to the centre of commercial strategy. Companies increasingly describe themselves as carbon neutral, net zero, sustainable, eco-friendly or climate positive. As sustainability claims become more commercially valuable, they also become more legally significant.

The question for businesses is no longer simply whether an ESG statement is good for the brand. It is whether the statement can be substantiated, appropriately qualified and defended if challenged. That is where greenwashing becomes a legal risk.

Greenwashing is generally understood as making environmental or sustainability claims that create a misleading impression about a company’s products, operations or environmental performance.

Legal exposure does not necessarily depend on deliberate deception. A claim made in good faith can still create liability if its methodology is inadequate, its data incomplete or its wording materially overstated. The critical question is whether it was sufficiently accurate and supported by evidence when made.

Environmental claims increasingly influence purchasing decisions. A statement that a product is “100% sustainable” or “carbon neutral” is not merely branding if consumers are likely to rely upon it. Where a claim cannot be objectively substantiated, the company may face scrutiny under applicable advertising, consumer protection and fair trading laws.

For example, describing a product as “carbon neutral” where the assertion depends principally on purchasing offsets rather than materially reducing associated emissions may create a misleading impression if that qualification is not properly communicated. The principle is straightforward: define the claim, identify the evidence and ensure that the evidence supports it.

The risk becomes more consequential when sustainability statements enter investor communications. Annual reports, offering memoranda, investor presentations and sustainability reports may contain statements concerning climate strategy, emissions reductions, transition plans and ESG performance. Depending on the applicable legal framework, inaccurate or misleading disclosures may raise issues concerning securities regulation, disclosure obligations, directors’ duties and potential investor claims.

There is a fundamental distinction between saying, “We have reduced our emissions by 30%,” and, “We intend to reduce our emissions by 30% by 2030.” The first is a statement of fact; the second is a forward-looking commitment. Each requires a different evidential framework.

A purchaser may require a supplier to warrant compliance with environmental standards. A lender may impose sustainability-linked conditions. An investor may require representations concerning ESG policies, emissions data or regulatory compliance.

Once an ESG statement becomes a contractual representation, it may become a promise upon which another party relies. An inaccurate sustainability representation may consequently result in contractual claims, indemnity exposure, termination rights or disputes concerning breach.

ESG due diligence should therefore examine what claims a target has made, what evidence supports them and whether those claims have been incorporated into contracts or financing arrangements.

Regulators are increasingly interested in the integrity of environmental claims. Companies are expected to demonstrate the evidential basis for material sustainability statements rather than rely on broad aspirational language.

For businesses operating across jurisdictions, the challenge is greater because regulatory requirements may differ between markets.

The consequences can also extend beyond regulatory action. A challenged sustainability claim can trigger reputational damage, investor scrutiny, customer concerns and commercial disputes. For businesses whose value proposition depends heavily on sustainability, the impact can be significant.

The answer is not to stop making sustainability commitments, but to impose greater discipline around how they are developed and communicated. Before a material environmental claim is published, businesses should ask:

  1. What exactly are we claiming?
  2. What evidence supports the claim?
  3. Who has verified the underlying information?
  4. What qualifications or limitations should be disclosed?
  5. Where else does the statement appear across advertising, reports, contracts, financing documents and investor communications?

Greenwashing should ultimately be treated as a governance issue. Boards should understand what their companies are saying about sustainability, the evidence supporting those statements and the legal consequences if those statements prove inaccurate. The central principle remains: an ESG claim is only as strong as the evidence behind it.

Companies need not have perfect environmental performance to speak credibly about sustainability. They do, however, need to distinguish between what they have achieved, committed to achieving and merely aspire to achieve.

As ESG considerations influence purchasing, investment, financing and commercial decisions, sustainability statements have acquired clear legal significance.

Greenwashing is therefore not merely a PR problem. It is a legal risk at the intersection of advertising, consumer protection, securities disclosure, contractual liability, regulatory compliance and corporate governance.

The prudent approach is not necessarily to say less about sustainability. It is to say only what the evidence can support. That discipline is increasingly important for boards, management teams and advisers alike.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *