Environmental, social and governance (“ESG”) strategy is often formulated at board and executive level. Policies are approved, targets are announced and reporting frameworks are adopted.
The more difficult question is what happens afterwards.
For organisations that own, occupy or manage significant real estate, a substantial part of ESG performance is determined not in the boardroom but in the day-to-day operation of their buildings: how much energy and water they consume, how waste is managed, how contractors are appointed and supervised, how health and safety risks are addressed, and how reliable the underlying data is.
This is where facility management (“FM”) becomes an ESG issue.
The proposition is increasingly reflected in the way the real estate sector measures sustainability performance. GRESB, for example, assesses real estate entities across management, risk management, stakeholder engagement and operational performance, including energy, greenhouse gas emissions, water, waste, data monitoring and building certifications.
From sustainability policy to operational reality
An ESG policy can establish an organisation’s objectives. It cannot, by itself, reduce energy consumption or improve workplace safety.
Those outcomes depend on operational decisions.
Consider a commercial building. Energy efficiency may depend upon the maintenance and performance of HVAC systems; water efficiency upon building systems and maintenance practices; waste outcomes upon procurement and disposal arrangements; and employee wellbeing upon factors ranging from indoor environmental quality to security, accessibility and emergency preparedness.
The environmental and social dimensions of ESG therefore increasingly intersect with the ordinary responsibilities of the facilities team.
This is particularly relevant in emerging markets, where the expansion of the built environment creates both a significant sustainability challenge and a substantial opportunity to improve resource efficiency. IFC estimates that investment in green buildings in emerging-market cities could reach US$24 trillion over the coming decade and identifies energy and resource efficiency as important drivers of both emissions reduction and cost savings.
The governance gap
The less obvious issue is governance.
It is relatively straightforward for an organisation to state that it is committed to sustainability. It is considerably harder to demonstrate that commitment through its contracts, procurement processes, maintenance records, supplier oversight and operational data.
That distinction matters.
If an organisation reports reductions in energy consumption, can it substantiate the underlying data? If it requires contractors to comply with ESG standards, are those obligations reflected in the contracts and monitored in practice? If a building is subject to health and safety requirements, who is responsible for identifying and escalating non-compliance?
These are governance questions as much as facilities questions.
Indeed, GRESB’s current framework places considerable emphasis on governance, risk management and reporting at entity level alongside asset-level environmental performance.
Contracts are an important part of the solution
For asset owners and occupiers, one of the most practical ways to integrate ESG into FM is through contract design.
Facilities management agreements, cleaning and waste-management contracts, security arrangements, maintenance agreements and property management contracts can incorporate measurable requirements relating to:
- energy and water efficiency;
- waste reduction and responsible disposal;
- occupational health and safety;
- responsible sourcing and procurement;
- labour and human-rights standards;
- incident reporting;
- data collection and verification;
- regulatory compliance; and
- audit and performance-monitoring rights.
The objective should not be to insert generic ESG language into every contract. The better approach is to identify the ESG risks that are actually material to the asset and translate them into obligations that can be measured and enforced.
The asset-management perspective
This matters increasingly to investors and lenders.
Sustainability performance is becoming part of the information used to assess real assets, with investors and lenders increasingly looking for consistent and validated information about operational performance and risk. GRESB’s real estate assessment is expressly designed to provide such information to capital markets.
For owners and developers, therefore, ESG considerations can affect more than reputation. They may influence operating costs, access to capital, tenant expectations, asset resilience and ultimately the long-term attractiveness of an asset.
Green-building frameworks such as IFC’s EDGE also demonstrate the commercial dimension of resource efficiency: qualifying projects must demonstrate projected reductions in energy, water and embodied energy in materials, while IFC identifies potential operational and financial benefits associated with more efficient buildings.
What should boards and management teams be asking?
The appropriate question is no longer simply:
“Do we have an ESG policy?”
It is:
“Can we demonstrate that our ESG commitments are reflected in the way our assets are operated?”
For organisations with significant property or facilities portfolios, that means considering whether:
- ESG responsibilities are clearly allocated between the board, management, property teams and FM providers;
- operational ESG risks are incorporated into enterprise risk management;
- FM and property-management contracts contain appropriate and measurable ESG obligations;
- contractors are subject to appropriate due diligence and performance monitoring;
- energy, water, waste and emissions data is reliable and capable of verification;
- health, safety and wellbeing risks are actively monitored; and
- management receives sufficient information to identify underperformance and intervene.
The distinction between ESG policy and ESG performance is becoming increasingly important. A policy describes an intention. Operational systems provide the evidence.
For property owners, developers, investors and occupiers, facility management is therefore no longer simply about keeping the lights on and the building running. It is increasingly part of how an organisation manages regulatory exposure, operational risk, asset value and the credibility of its ESG commitments.
At Manoah & Company Advocates, we advise facility managers, property owners, developers, businesses and institutions on ESG, real estate, corporate governance, regulatory compliance and commercial contracting, including the development of practical frameworks that translate ESG objectives into operational and contractual requirements.
