Nairobi skyline for business-focused legal counsel in Kenya
Thought Leadership

Business-focused legal counsel.

Business-focused counsel for companies, institutions, investors and private clients.

ESG  is moving out of corporate policies and into the contractual architecture of business. For years, ESG commitments have largely lived in sustainability reports, corporate policies, codes of conduct and investor presentations. That is changing.

Increasingly, environmental, social and governance expectations are being translated into contractual obligations: obligations imposed on suppliers, contractors, distributors, service providers, joint venture partners and other business counterparties.

For commercial lawyers, this represents an important shift. The question is no longer simply whether a business has an ESG policy. It is whether its contracts actually give that policy legal effect.

A statement that a company is committed to responsible sourcing, human rights, climate action or ethical business conduct may be useful from a policy perspective. But a policy does not necessarily answer the commercial questions that arise when a supplier breaches those commitments.

What happens if a critical supplier uses prohibited labour practices?

What if a contractor breaches environmental requirements?

What if a supplier refuses to provide emissions data required for the company’s sustainability reporting?

What if a business partner’s conduct creates a regulatory, reputational or financing risk for the company?

And, importantly, what contractual rights does the company have to respond?

This is where ESG clauses become significant. Sustainability due diligence regimes increasingly contemplate engagement with business partners and contractual assurances as part of managing environmental and human-rights risks across value chains. The EU’s Corporate Sustainability Due Diligence framework, for example, expressly contemplates contractual assurances from business partners, together with measures to verify compliance.

At the same time, sustainability reporting frameworks increasingly require companies to understand risks and opportunities across their value chains. IFRS S2, for example, requires consideration of Scope 3 emissions across relevant upstream and downstream value-chain categories. The consequence is important. A company’s sustainability obligations increasingly depend on information and conduct sitting outside the company’s “four walls”. Contracts are therefore becoming one of the principal mechanisms through which ESG expectations are operationalised.

There is no universal ESG clause. The appropriate drafting will depend on the transaction, the sector, the counterparty, the jurisdiction, the company’s risk profile and the materiality of the relevant ESG issues. But there are several contractual building blocks that deserve careful consideration.

Supplier codes of conduct

For businesses with significant supply chains, the supplier code of conduct is often the starting point. A supplier code can establish minimum standards covering areas such as:

The important drafting question is whether the code is merely incorporated by reference or whether compliance with specified provisions is expressly made a contractual obligation. That distinction matters. If a code is intended to be enforceable, the contract should make clear which obligations apply, how they are incorporated, how conflicts between the code and the main agreement are resolved and what consequences follow from non-compliance.

Environmental obligations

Environmental obligations should be calibrated to the nature of the transaction. For some contracts, this may involve relatively straightforward compliance with applicable environmental laws and permits. For others, the obligations may be considerably more specific.

A construction contract, for example, may address waste management, pollution prevention, environmental permits, biodiversity impacts and remediation. A manufacturing or supply agreement may address emissions, hazardous materials, energy consumption, water use or waste. A logistics agreement may address fleet emissions, fuel efficiency or reporting requirements.

The key is to avoid drafting environmental obligations at a level of abstraction that makes them difficult to measure or enforce. “The supplier shall operate sustainably” is not a particularly useful contractual obligation. A stronger clause identifies the relevant standard, metric, methodology or performance requirement.

Human-rights warranties

Human-rights provisions are increasingly moving beyond general statements of principle. Depending on the risk profile of the transaction, warranties may address:

The drafting should also consider whether these obligations apply only to the contracting entity or extend into its supply chain. That is particularly important where the commercial counterparty is effectively the gateway to a much larger network of suppliers.

Audit and access rights

An ESG obligation without a mechanism for verification can become difficult to enforce in practice. Contracts should therefore consider whether the customer or principal should have rights to:

The scope of these rights should, however, be proportionate. Unlimited audit rights can create unnecessary operational burdens, particularly for smaller suppliers. A sophisticated contractual framework will distinguish between routine monitoring and enhanced investigation triggered by a material concern.

Reporting and information obligations

This is likely to become one of the most important elements of ESG contracting. A company cannot report information that it cannot obtain. Where sustainability reporting depends on data generated by suppliers, contractors or other counterparties, contracts need to address the flow of information through the value chain. Depending on the business, this may include obligations to provide:

The contract should also address the quality, timing, methodology and verification of the information supplied. This is particularly relevant as companies increasingly deal with value-chain reporting requirements. IFRS S1 and S2 place significant emphasis on sustainability-related risks, opportunities and value-chain information, including Scope 3 emissions. In other words: ESG data is increasingly becoming contractual data.

Subcontractor compliance

An ESG obligation imposed only on the primary supplier may provide limited protection where the actual risk sits further down the supply chain. Contracts should therefore consider whether the supplier is required to:

This is where ESG clauses begin to resemble traditional contractual risk-allocation mechanisms. The objective is not simply to say: “Our supplier must comply.” It is to establish who is responsible for how compliance is demonstrated and what happens when it fails.

Termination rights

Termination is often the most obvious contractual remedy and, unfortunately, one of the most poorly considered. Not every ESG breach should trigger immediate termination. A minor reporting delay should not necessarily have the same contractual consequence as forced labour, a serious environmental breach or deliberate falsification of ESG data. A well-designed clause must therefore distinguish between remediable breaches and material or fundamental breaches. This allows the contract to reflect the severity, likelihood and reversibility of the underlying risk.

Indemnities and liability allocation

Where ESG risks could result in significant third-party claims, regulatory exposure, remediation costs or reputational damage, the parties should consider whether specific indemnities are appropriate. Potential areas may include losses arising from:

But ESG indemnities should not simply become a drafting exercise in shifting every conceivable sustainability risk to the counterparty. The more important question is which party is best placed to identify, control and mitigate the risk. That is a fundamentally commercial question.

The Kenyan perspective

For Kenyan businesses, ESG contracting should not be viewed as an imported compliance exercise relevant only to multinational groups. There is already a broader legal and governance context within which these issues sit.

The Companies Act requires directors, in promoting the success of a company, to have regard to matters including the long-term consequences of decisions, relationships with suppliers and customers, the impact of the company’s operations on the community and environment, and the desirability of maintaining high standards of business conduct. Directors are also subject to duties concerning independent judgement and conflicts of interest.

Similarly, Kenya’s Climate Change Act provides a framework for climate-change response and expressly contemplates private-sector contribution to low-carbon, climate-resilient development.

These developments do not mean that every Kenyan commercial contract requires an extensive ESG schedule. They do, however, reinforce a broader proposition that ESG is increasingly relevant to how companies manage risk, make decisions and structure commercial relationships.

For businesses operating within international supply chains, the pressure may be even more direct. A Kenyan supplier may find that its multinational customer requires contractual commitments on emissions, labour practices, responsible sourcing, audit rights or human-rights due diligence, not because Kenyan law necessarily imposes that exact contractual obligation, but because the customer’s own regulatory, investor, financing or reporting requirements make the information and conduct commercially material. That is how ESG requirements travel through value chains.

There is a temptation to respond to this trend by inserting a broad ESG clause into every commercial agreement. That is not the best approach. An ESG provision should be risk-based and transaction-specific.

The relevant questions should include:

What is the ESG risk? – Is it environmental, labour-related, human-rights, governance, supply-chain or data-related?

Where does the risk sit? – With the customer? Supplier? Contractor? Subcontractor? Joint venture partner?

Can the risk be measured? – If so, what is the relevant metric, methodology or standard?

How will compliance be verified? – Through certification? Reporting? Audit? Independent assurance?

What happens if the obligation is breached? – Remediation? Corrective action? Suspension? Indemnity? Termination?

Who bears the cost? – The answer should follow the party best placed to control the underlying risk.

These are commercial questions as much as ESG questions.

One of the most common weaknesses in ESG contracting is a disconnect between the company’s stated commitments and its contractual remedies. A company may have an impressive sustainability policy. It may have ambitious net-zero commitments. It may have a detailed human-rights policy. But if its principal supplier agreement contains none of those obligations, and provides no meaningful mechanism for verification or remediation, there may be a significant gap between policy and contractual reality. The better approach is to build a coherent contractual chain.

This is where the role of the commercial lawyer becomes particularly important. The task is not simply to insert ESG language. It is to translate an organisation’s ESG objectives into clear, measurable and commercially workable obligations.

What should businesses be doing now?

Companies do not need to wait for a regulatory mandate before reviewing their contracts. A practical starting point is to undertake an ESG contract audit. Review the company’s material supplier, procurement, construction, services, distribution, financing, investment and joint venture agreements and ask:

  1. What ESG commitments has the company already made publicly or internally?
  2. Which of those commitments depend on third parties?
  3. Are those obligations reflected in the relevant contracts?
  4. Can the company obtain the ESG information it needs from counterparties?
  5. Does it have appropriate audit and verification rights?
  6. Are subcontractors appropriately captured?
  7. Are breaches capable of being remediated?
  8. Are material breaches linked to meaningful contractual remedies?
  9. Are liability and indemnity provisions aligned with the underlying ESG risk?
  10. Do the contracts support, rather than undermine, the company’s broader ESG strategy?

The answers may reveal that the organisation does not have an ESG policy problem. It has a contracting problem.

The evolution of ESG contracting is not really about adding another clause to the back of a 60-page agreement. It is about a broader shift in how commercial risk is understood. Environmental performance, human-rights practices, supply-chain integrity, emissions data and responsible business conduct are increasingly capable of affecting cost, access to finance, regulatory exposure, reputation, business continuity, investor confidence and ultimately enterprise value. That means ESG is moving closer to the traditional territory of commercial law: risk allocation, warranties, conditions precedent, information rights, audit rights, indemnities, liability and termination.

The sophisticated contract of the future will not treat ESG as an appendix. It will treat material ESG risks as part of the commercial bargain itself.

The ESG clause is coming. For some businesses, it is already here. The question for boards, management teams and legal advisers is therefore not whether ESG belongs in commercial contracts. It is where it belongs, how far it should go, and whether the contractual framework actually protects the business. That requires more than an ESG policy. It requires commercially intelligent drafting.

At Manoah & Company Advocates, we advise businesses, investors and organisations on the intersection of commercial contracting, ESG, governance and regulatory risk, helping clients translate strategic commitments into practical contractual protections.

For further information or to discuss an ESG contracting or contract review mandate, please contact info@manoahadvocates.co.ke.

This article is provided for general information purposes and does not constitute legal advice. The appropriate contractual approach will depend on the circumstances of each transaction and the applicable legal and regulatory framework.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *