Nairobi skyline for business-focused legal counsel in Kenya
Thought Leadership

Business-focused legal counsel.

Business-focused counsel for companies, institutions, investors and private clients.

What the Royal Mabati–Vintage Mabati dispute illustrates about intellectual property protection, employee exits and competitive risk in Kenya.

A business may spend years building a name that customers recognise, trust and associate with quality. Yet the legal protection afforded to that investment does not begin and end with registering a company name or securing a trade mark.

Brand identity, product designs, confidential information, customer relationships and accumulated goodwill may represent some of a company’s most valuable commercial assets. They may also become particularly vulnerable when employees, consultants or business partners leave and subsequently enter the same market.

A recent dispute between Royal Mabati Factory Limited and Vintage Mabati Mills Limited brings these issues into sharp focus.

The dispute, which is before the High Court in Nairobi, concerns allegations of infringement involving trademarks, designs and branding. Royal Mabati alleges, among other matters, that former consultants who had access to its knowledge and proprietary information subsequently established a competing business using marks, colours, logos and branding alleged to be substantially similar to those associated with Royal Mabati.

The defendants dispute the allegations and maintain, among other things, that any resemblance was inadvertent and arose from terminology and branding concepts commonly used within the roofing industry. The court has granted interim protection in respect of the disputed branding, while making clear that the substantive questions of infringement, passing off and related liability remain to be determined at trial.

The significance of the dispute therefore extends beyond the parties themselves. It illustrates a recurring commercial question: How does a business protect the value it has created when the people who helped build that value subsequently become competitors?

For many businesses, intellectual property protection is approached primarily as an administrative exercise: register the company name, register the logo and move on. Intellectual property is a commercial asset, not merely a registration. That approach can leave significant gaps.

A company’s commercial identity may comprise a portfolio of rights and interests, including:

The legal protection available to each category is different. More importantly, the evidence required to enforce those rights may differ. A sophisticated IP strategy therefore begins with identifying what the business actually owns, how those assets are used and where the principal risks of misappropriation lie.

Competition is not, in itself, unlawful. A former employee, consultant or business partner may in many circumstances establish or join a competing business. The legal issue arises when competition involves conduct that infringes protected rights or unlawfully appropriates another business’s confidential information, goodwill or other proprietary assets.

This distinction is commercially important. A competitor may sell an equivalent product. It may target the same customers. It may compete on price, quality or distribution. What it cannot necessarily do is create a market identity so similar to that of an established business that customers are likely to believe that the two businesses are connected, or reproduce protected intellectual property without lawful justification.

That is why disputes of this nature frequently extend beyond trade mark infringement to questions of passing off, goodwill, confidential information and contractual obligations. The legal analysis must therefore look at the complete commercial picture rather than simply comparing two names.

The circumstances alleged in the Royal Mabati dispute highlight another issue that businesses often underestimate: the concentration of commercially sensitive information in individuals. Employees and consultants may have access to information concerning:

Once that information has been disclosed, the practical challenge is controlling its use after the relationship ends. This is why confidentiality should not be treated as boilerplate contractual language. Businesses should identify, with some precision, what information is confidential, who has access to it, why they have access to it and what happens when their engagement ends.

Exit processes are equally important. Access to systems, customer databases, shared drives, proprietary software and other repositories of confidential information should be reviewed and, where appropriate, withdrawn promptly when an individual leaves.

One of the clearest lessons for businesses is that enforcement becomes significantly easier when ownership and use of intellectual property have been properly documented from the outset. A business should be able to answer basic questions such as:

Who owns the trade mark?

Who owns the logo and marketing materials?

Were the designs created by employees, consultants or external agencies?

Are those ownership rights documented in writing?

Which marks are registered and in which classes?

Have registrations been renewed and properly maintained?

What evidence exists of the brand’s use and reputation in the market?

What contractual protections apply when an employee or consultant leaves?

These questions can become critical when urgent injunctive relief is required. The stronger the underlying documentation, the easier it is to establish the proprietary interest that requires protection.

The Royal Mabati dispute also provides a useful reminder about the strategic role of interim remedies. In commercial IP disputes, a claimant may seek urgent protection before the court has determined the substantive dispute. This may be particularly important where continued use of a mark or branding could cause customer confusion or further damage goodwill.

In this case, the court considered that Royal Mabati had demonstrated an identifiable proprietary interest deserving protection pending trial and temporarily restrained use of the disputed branding. At the same time, the court declined to freeze Vintage Mabati’s operating accounts and refused immediate orders for an accounting of profits or destruction of disputed products, considering those remedies disproportionate or premature before liability had been established.

The distinction is important. An interim injunction protects the position pending determination of the dispute. It does not, by itself, establish that infringement has occurred.

Businesses contemplating urgent court action should therefore approach interim relief as part of a broader litigation strategy, supported by evidence of ownership, use, reputation, similarity, likely confusion and the potential consequences of continued conduct.

What should businesses do differently?

The practical lesson is not simply to register a trade mark. Businesses should consider a more integrated approach to intellectual property and competitive risk.

1. Map the IP portfolio

Identify the brands, product names, designs, content, confidential information and other intangible assets that create commercial value.

2. Confirm ownership

Where designers, consultants, agencies or contractors have created intellectual property, ensure that contractual arrangements clearly address ownership and permitted use.

3. Register strategically

Registration should be considered not merely for the corporate name but for the marks and designs that are commercially significant to the business, in the relevant jurisdictions and classes.

4. Strengthen confidentiality protections

Confidentiality provisions should reflect the actual information that the business needs to protect. Access controls and internal policies should support the contractual protections.

5. Build robust exit procedures

When senior employees, consultants or other personnel leave, businesses should consider access rights, confidentiality obligations, return of property, deletion of information and continuing contractual restrictions.

6. Monitor the market

Registration alone does not prevent third parties from adopting potentially problematic marks. Businesses should monitor competitors and the market for potentially infringing activity.

7. Preserve evidence

Where infringement or misuse is suspected, businesses should preserve evidence before confronting the alleged infringer or commencing proceedings. Screenshots, advertisements, product samples, customer communications, registration records and evidence of historical use can become important litigation evidence.

The broader commercial lesson

The value of a business is increasingly found in assets that do not appear on its balance sheet. A recognisable brand, a trusted market identity, proprietary designs, customer relationships and accumulated know-how can represent years of investment. Losing control of those assets can therefore have consequences extending well beyond a conventional IP dispute.

The Royal Mabati–Vintage Mabati proceedings are still at an interlocutory stage, and the allegations remain contested. The court will ultimately determine the substantive issues on the evidence presented at trial.

For businesses, however, the broader lesson is already clear. Intellectual property protection should not begin when infringement occurs. It should be built into the way the business is structured, documented, managed and exited.

For companies operating in competitive markets, the question is therefore not simply whether a valuable brand has been registered. It is whether the business has built the contractual, operational and legal architecture necessary to protect that brand when competition becomes more aggressive.

That is ultimately where effective IP protection moves from registration to strategy.

At Manoah & Company Advocates, we advise businesses on protecting the intellectual property, commercial information and contractual relationships that underpin their competitive position. This includes trade mark and design protection, IP ownership and licensing, confidentiality arrangements, employee and consultant exits, restrictive covenants and enforcement strategy where infringement or misuse is suspected. Our approach is to identify these risks early and build practical legal protections around the business before a dispute arises.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *