Nairobi skyline for business-focused legal counsel in Kenya
Thought Leadership

Business-focused legal counsel.

Business-focused counsel for companies, institutions, investors and private clients.

ESG risk is increasingly becoming litigation risk. For companies, the significance lies less in the emergence of a distinct category of “ESG litigation” than in the extent to which existing causes of action are being reframed through environmental, social and governance considerations.

Environmental claims, shareholder actions, regulatory proceedings, contractual disputes and challenges to corporate decision-making can all acquire an ESG dimension. The resulting exposure may extend beyond the underlying conduct to questions of what the board knew, what it was told, how it responded and whether the company’s public statements accurately reflected its position.

From Commitment to Accountability

Companies are making increasingly specific commitments on climate, sustainability, responsible sourcing, human rights and community engagement. Those commitments may create expectations among shareholders, regulators, employees, communities and commercial counterparties.

The legal risk arises where there is a material disconnect between corporate commitments, operational conduct and disclosure.

A company’s failure to substantiate a sustainability claim may attract allegations of misleading disclosure. Environmental or community-related failures may result in regulatory intervention or civil claims. Weak supply-chain oversight may create contractual or reputational exposure. In each case, conduct that may previously have been regarded principally as a sustainability matter can become a question of legal liability.

The Governance Implications

The development is particularly relevant to boards.

Where ESG matters are capable of affecting enterprise value, regulatory compliance or the company’s ability to operate, they increasingly fall within the broader framework of enterprise risk and board oversight.

This raises familiar governance questions: whether material risks were appropriately identified; whether directors received sufficient and reliable information; whether management’s response was adequately challenged; and whether the basis for significant decisions was properly documented.

The evidential record may become as important as the decision itself.

This is particularly relevant where shareholders challenge corporate decisions or disclosures. A board that can demonstrate a considered process, supported by appropriate information and documented deliberation, is in a materially stronger position than one whose ESG oversight exists principally through policies and public statements.

Preparing for the next phase of ESG risk

Companies should therefore consider whether material ESG risks are appropriately integrated into their enterprise risk and governance frameworks, whether public statements can be substantiated and whether significant ESG-related decisions are subject to appropriate board oversight and documentation.

This does not require boards to eliminate ESG risk, nor does it mean that every sustainability issue is a litigation risk. It requires material ESG considerations to be governed with the same discipline applied to other matters capable of affecting the company’s legal or commercial position.

As ESG expectations become more closely connected with corporate accountability, the distinction between ESG risk and conventional legal risk will become increasingly difficult to maintain.

For boards, the practical question is therefore not whether ESG belongs within the litigation risk framework, but whether the company’s governance processes would withstand scrutiny if an ESG-related decision were challenged.

Manoah & Company Advocates advises companies, boards and investors on ESG, corporate governance, regulatory compliance, risk management and complex disputes across Africa. Please reach us through info@manoahadvocates.co.ke .

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *